Wednesday, October 6, 2010

EDUC C262 Blog

In their paper Imel and Stein wrote, “Adult learning in the United States has a decidedly individualistic rather than a communal nature” (117). This statement stood out to me because it is so true and also because it is the reason community learning is often underused in our classrooms. So many students dread the idea of working in a group or having to rely on a community of students to complete an assignment. Few students realize the potential community learning offers and don’t like having to rely on others for a grade. But the term “social capital” reflects the idea that social networking and groups can be a great resource for learning and growing. Students can learn from each other as well as from the instructor. Recent trends in education have seen this and have been advocating more community learning in the classroom. Last fall I attended an On Course workshop that offered instructors many ideas about using different group and community activities to promote a different kind of learning as an alternative to lecturing.

For online classes, the need for community is even more important as students are physically isolated from fellow students and the class instructor. In “Building Sense of Community at a Distance,” Rovai writes that a classroom community needs four dimensions: cohesion or spirit among the classroom community, trust, interaction, and learning. In my own online classroom experience, these dimensions can occur in a well-structured online course, even without putting students in smaller groups. I actually think a learning community is easier to create for students in an online class compared to a face-to-face class.

In an online class, cohesion can be created at the beginning of the course when students introduce themselves and they understand the similarities between each other and/or their ultimate goals. In my experience, students are more willing to share information about themselves in the online environment where they don’t have to stand up and “speak” in front of the whole class. Discussion rooms like the “virtual café” also help to create this sense of community among those who seek it. Trust is probably the hardest dimension to create among students, especially in smaller groups where a grade depends on the whole team contributing. But as in this class, when an instructor gives both an individual grade and a group grade, trust is more easily given. I also think respect and giving students classroom guidelines for class interaction will help create a stronger trust among students. If students respond to each other with respect and quality feedback, a better trust can be formed. For the online class, interaction is more easily achieved than in the face-to-face classroom because students must post their thoughts in an online class for others to read and give feedback to. There is no hiding in an online class. Most instructors require students to respond to other students’ postings, so interaction is automatically a part of online learning. If I were to teach an online class, I would also require students respond to other students who haven’t had feedback yet, so everyone would have the chance for a classroom “conversation.” Lastly, I think learning takes place among these three dimensions as well as in the course material the students may be reading. To me, learning is the product of all the other dimensions. And because online students can go back and reread material, there is a greater sense of understanding and learning taking place among this cohesion, trust and interaction.

9 comments:

  1. Hi Leah,

    This is a very detailed conversation about the online forum. I have never taught an online course, so I related my (much more brief) blog to how I could use it in my currently classroom. There is certainly a lot of practical uses for blogs, not only in the online environment, but also in the classroom setting.

    I certainly agree about the different ways learning takes place, and as instructors I believe it is best that we know as many as possible.

    Great job,

    Ben Beshwate

    ReplyDelete
  2. Leah,

    I'd be interested in more info on that workshop offering ideas for activities.

    That said, two days ago I would have agreed that there is a greater need to create a community in an online class. Over the last day, I am beginning to think that the whole purpose of an online class is to provide flexibility to the student. Groups have a way of forcing students to come together at the same time - synchronous interaction. I might argue that an online class that forces too much synchronous interaction is not providing any more flexibility to a student than an on-campus class.

    I have only taken the online classes so far in this program and they are extremely short and fast paced - so maybe my view is skewed a bit.

    Anyway, thanks for the thought provoking post.

    -Mike B from class.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Ben,

    This is my first time using a blog, and it seems like a very useful tool. It does feel strange to have your thoughts out there for everyone to read. What ways would you use a blog in a classroom setting? It sounds like a great idea.

    Leah

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Mike,

    Go to the website: www.oncourseworkshop.com and you will find lots of teaching strategies. The workshop was really good and I used several of the strategies in my own class.

    I agree that online classes should provide students with more flexibility, which seems like its purpose. And you are correct that too much synchronous doesn’t allow for that flexibility. It seems many students take online classes so they can log in at the hours of their convenience, but synchronous interaction doesn’t match with that. A lot of online classes at my college require on-campus meeting, which I also think goes against the flexibility of an online class also. The college certainly can’t attract students from a far distance with an on-campus requirement. But I really believe you can create a community within an online class without synchronous interaction.

    Leah

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think your assessment of why students (and everyone else) don’t like working in groups is spot on. So that even thought are great rewards and benefits to working in groups, most people have not experienced them, so they think it is just a myth!

    While you are correct in saying no one can hide in an on-line environment, that still doesn’t guarantee or encourage participation as we have seen from this class. I think your comments about how to do that were helpful. I would like to hear more about strategies you know of or have learned that helped with this.

    The dilemma for me that I see is when there is an evaluative element to posting comments, even if only to count them, that takes away from some of the authenticity. I understand the need for assessment and evaluation, but since that is such a subjective matter, even with pre-defined criteria, it often feels like comparing apples and oranges.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Nancy,

    You're very right, there is no guarantee everyone will participate in online group activities. I think that is the hard part in both online and traditional classes. And when someone doesn't participate, it can ruin doing group work for the others members in future. But hopefully those that do participate learn from each other and take away new perspectives from the process.

    In response to your comments about grading posted comments, in online classes I have taken, the instructors were very detailed in explaining how they wanted responses. They would give a word count, explain they wanted analytical responses or detailed responses. If I even teach an online class, I think this is want I will do, and even give a grading criteria for posting replies.

    Leah

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Leah,
    I can understand why someone would be more willing to share information about themselves online than in person at the beginning of an online course. Know one is actually looking at you in an online course. People are only looking at what you write, therefore you feel less vulnerable. Over time people warm up to each other and trust increases no matter what type of class it is. What would be interesting to know is, if greater trust is typically achieved in a regular class over time than in an online class.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Leah,
    Very well stated. I also think like you a lot of student's don't like doing group work because they don't like relying on other people, but in an online class I believe it is different as you mentioned. In an online class student's don't have to worry about getting together face to face with their group nor do they have to get in front of the class to speak. Therefore, I believe that online classes are a lot easier for students because of the fact that some of those aspects are not present like in face to face situations. That makes it easier for students and a little less stressful for some of the shy students. Therefore, online is a lot less personal, but a lot more productive for many students.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Leah,

    Great detailed post! You stated "a learning community is easier to create for students in an online class compared to a face-to-face class." How can a facilitator maintain the sense of community and social capital in a course?

    Thanks,
    April

    ReplyDelete